{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "kind": "odin-rnd.results",
  "experiment": "EXP 021",
  "date": "2026-11-11",
  "measuredFrom": "2026-11-08T10:17:44Z",
  "measuredThrough": "2026-11-10T14:25:14Z",
  "summary": "MongoDB fits six of eight compared scenarios on the selected timing metric: four on write outage and two on acknowledgement gap; PostgreSQL fits both peer-only partition scenarios through the feed gate. No overall winner. Strict-ack and disturbance uncertainties remain.",
  "sourceCommit": "d5e74de709cfe0ab0e6ef575cdefd28bdaf6ae97",
  "sourceVerdictSha256": "d2e7a0294d9158f1db6bba89b180a72d03135359a2dc02672fbbcee4b233e9fb",
  "verdict": {
    "scenarios": {
      "default/F1": {
        "verdict": "mongodb-fits",
        "basis": "outage",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 20.8747,
              "pg": 36.114
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.3844,
              "pg": 29.8535
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.7253,
              "pg": 25.5455
            },
            {
              "mongo": 20.8585,
              "pg": 30.0085
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.7061,
              "pg": 35.6122
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 10.6234,
              "pg": 35.1979
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.6237,
              "pg": 36.5879
            },
            {
              "mongo": 12.0563,
              "pg": 25.7791
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.6318,
              "pg": 36.5632
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.6219,
              "pg": 36.4862
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 5,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": -24.9642,
        "pg_variant": "classic-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "outbox"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": false,
        "compared_metric": "outage"
      },
      "overhead:default/F1": {
        "verdict": "mongodb-fits",
        "basis": "outage",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 20.8747,
              "pg": 36.5217
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.3844,
              "pg": 28.5349
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.7253,
              "pg": 28.0406
            },
            {
              "mongo": 20.8585,
              "pg": 28.3539
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.7061,
              "pg": 34.915
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 5,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": null,
        "pg_variant": "outbox-only",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "outbox"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "outbox-only",
            "outbox-only",
            "outbox-only",
            "outbox-only",
            "outbox-only"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        }
      },
      "default/F1b": {
        "verdict": "both-fit",
        "basis": "outage rule not met",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 10.5922,
              "pg": 10.132
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.5497,
              "pg": 5.161
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.6465,
              "pg": 10.1704
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.6335,
              "pg": 10.1437
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.3992,
              "pg": 5.1456
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 11.691,
              "pg": 10.1631
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.1804,
              "pg": 5.159
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.4928,
              "pg": 10.1534
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.4065,
              "pg": 5.1556
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.4115,
              "pg": 10.1703
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 0,
          "pg": 2
        },
        "repro_median_diff": null,
        "pg_variant": "quorum-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "slot"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": true,
        "compared_metric": "outage"
      },
      "default/F2a": {
        "verdict": "mongodb-fits",
        "basis": "outage",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 17.9804,
              "pg": 35.263
            },
            {
              "mongo": 24.3601,
              "pg": 31.6126
            },
            {
              "mongo": 18.9057,
              "pg": 27.1676
            },
            {
              "mongo": 17.6783,
              "pg": 35.8478
            },
            {
              "mongo": 17.31,
              "pg": 26.3557
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 22.8177,
              "pg": 27.4471
            },
            {
              "mongo": 17.3902,
              "pg": 27.1364
            },
            {
              "mongo": 22.747,
              "pg": 35.5858
            },
            {
              "mongo": 17.9072,
              "pg": 26.9111
            },
            {
              "mongo": 17.8998,
              "pg": 31.4367
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 5,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": -9.7462,
        "pg_variant": "quorum-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "outbox"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": false,
        "compared_metric": "outage"
      },
      "default/F2b": {
        "verdict": "postgres-fits",
        "basis": "gate-only",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 21.3407,
              "pg": 34.9322
            },
            {
              "mongo": 20.6212,
              "pg": 34.7721
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.5919,
              "pg": 35.1138
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.9317,
              "pg": 35.2664
            },
            {
              "mongo": 18.7645,
              "pg": 34.9186
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 11.8708,
              "pg": 25.3527
            },
            {
              "mongo": 24.6039,
              "pg": 35.1731
            },
            {
              "mongo": 18.6989,
              "pg": 26.544
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.7093,
              "pg": 34.6824
            },
            {
              "mongo": 17.3537,
              "pg": 34.775
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {},
        "repro_median_diff": null,
        "pg_variant": "quorum-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": null,
          "pg": "slot"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": "gate-only",
        "gates": {
          "mongo": false,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": false,
        "compared_metric": "outage"
      },
      "default/F3": {
        "verdict": "mongodb-fits",
        "basis": "outage",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 0.4064,
              "pg": 9.4733
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4091,
              "pg": 3.486
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4601,
              "pg": 3.477
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4133,
              "pg": 3.4696
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4048,
              "pg": 9.5098
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 0.5696,
              "pg": 10.5967
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4705,
              "pg": 3.4577
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4054,
              "pg": 3.5172
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4084,
              "pg": 9.4474
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4052,
              "pg": 3.4826
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 5,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": -3.1118,
        "pg_variant": "classic-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "slot"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": false,
        "compared_metric": "ack_gap"
      },
      "tuned/F1": {
        "verdict": "mongodb-fits",
        "basis": "outage",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 10.372,
              "pg": 20.5154
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1554,
              "pg": 20.9535
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.3417,
              "pg": 23.2344
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1319,
              "pg": 23.4946
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1035,
              "pg": 20.9965
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 10.3157,
              "pg": 21.2865
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1743,
              "pg": 20.6273
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.2784,
              "pg": 23.1617
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.2149,
              "pg": 21.1519
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.3996,
              "pg": 23.2241
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 5,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": -10.9708,
        "pg_variant": "quorum-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "outbox"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": false,
        "compared_metric": "outage"
      },
      "overhead:tuned/F1": {
        "verdict": "mongodb-fits",
        "basis": "outage",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 10.372,
              "pg": 23.2208
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1554,
              "pg": 20.9795
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.3417,
              "pg": 26.0382
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1319,
              "pg": 25.5441
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1035,
              "pg": 23.2173
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 5,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": null,
        "pg_variant": "outbox-only",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "outbox"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "outbox-only",
            "outbox-only",
            "outbox-only",
            "outbox-only",
            "outbox-only"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        }
      },
      "tuned/F1b": {
        "verdict": "both-fit",
        "basis": "outage rule not met",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 6.0304,
              "pg": 10.3991
            },
            {
              "mongo": 6.1232,
              "pg": 5.1586
            },
            {
              "mongo": 5.9074,
              "pg": 5.1431
            },
            {
              "mongo": 6.3441,
              "pg": 5.1469
            },
            {
              "mongo": 5.8809,
              "pg": 5.1586
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 6.073,
              "pg": 10.2492
            },
            {
              "mongo": 5.4802,
              "pg": 5.1475
            },
            {
              "mongo": 5.7471,
              "pg": 5.1539
            },
            {
              "mongo": 5.2107,
              "pg": 5.1485
            },
            {
              "mongo": 5.8821,
              "pg": 10.1639
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 1,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": null,
        "pg_variant": "quorum-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "slot"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": true,
        "compared_metric": "outage"
      },
      "tuned/F2a": {
        "verdict": "mongodb-fits",
        "basis": "outage",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 15.0905,
              "pg": 21.4601
            },
            {
              "mongo": 15.3246,
              "pg": 21.7231
            },
            {
              "mongo": 17.5226,
              "pg": 27.0087
            },
            {
              "mongo": 15.1017,
              "pg": 23.6467
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.3435,
              "pg": 21.5856
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 8.4645,
              "pg": 24.0302
            },
            {
              "mongo": 15.2968,
              "pg": 24.9611
            },
            {
              "mongo": 11.7142,
              "pg": 21.9326
            },
            {
              "mongo": 15.2115,
              "pg": 26.7197
            },
            {
              "mongo": 15.3415,
              "pg": 22.0069
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 5,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": -10.2184,
        "pg_variant": "classic-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "outbox"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": false,
        "compared_metric": "outage"
      },
      "tuned/F2b": {
        "verdict": "postgres-fits",
        "basis": "gate-only",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 10.2644,
              "pg": 25.2823
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.3535,
              "pg": 21.915
            },
            {
              "mongo": 15.187,
              "pg": 22.1809
            },
            {
              "mongo": 18.1776,
              "pg": 22.5257
            },
            {
              "mongo": 15.5153,
              "pg": 22.4697
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 0.4209,
              "pg": 24.9474
            },
            {
              "mongo": 15.1499,
              "pg": 25.1182
            },
            {
              "mongo": 15.2096,
              "pg": 25.0191
            },
            {
              "mongo": 17.1324,
              "pg": 21.8529
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1288,
              "pg": 24.8483
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {},
        "repro_median_diff": null,
        "pg_variant": "quorum-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": null,
          "pg": "slot"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": "gate-only",
        "gates": {
          "mongo": false,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": false,
        "compared_metric": "outage"
      },
      "tuned/F3": {
        "verdict": "mongodb-fits",
        "basis": "outage",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 0.4051,
              "pg": 3.5492
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4087,
              "pg": 3.4977
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.653,
              "pg": 9.5907
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4043,
              "pg": 3.4687
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4174,
              "pg": 3.5
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 0.8028,
              "pg": 9.5888
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4841,
              "pg": 9.485
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4083,
              "pg": 3.5595
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4048,
              "pg": 9.4439
            },
            {
              "mongo": 0.4053,
              "pg": 9.4726
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 5,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": -9.0009,
        "pg_variant": "quorum-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "slot"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "classic-strict",
            "classic-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        },
        "labelled_fault": false,
        "compared_metric": "ack_gap"
      },
      "floor/F1": {
        "verdict": "mongodb-fits",
        "basis": "outage",
        "pairs": {
          "1": [
            {
              "mongo": 10.372,
              "pg": 23.1595
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1554,
              "pg": 23.0906
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.3417,
              "pg": 25.5418
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1319,
              "pg": 25.5209
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1035,
              "pg": 23.7439
            }
          ],
          "2": [
            {
              "mongo": 10.3157,
              "pg": 23.7092
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.1743,
              "pg": 23.8598
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.2784,
              "pg": 23.2594
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.2149,
              "pg": 26.298
            },
            {
              "mongo": 10.3996,
              "pg": 23.2542
            }
          ]
        },
        "wins": {
          "mongo": 5,
          "pg": 0
        },
        "repro_median_diff": -13.3935,
        "pg_variant": "quorum-strict",
        "feeds": {
          "mongo": "stream",
          "pg": "outbox"
        },
        "flags": [],
        "per_rep_best": {
          "1": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ],
          "2": [
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict",
            "quorum-strict"
          ]
        },
        "label": null,
        "gates": {
          "mongo": true,
          "pg": true
        }
      }
    },
    "components": {
      "verdict": "postgres-fits",
      "basis": "gate-only",
      "label": "gate-only",
      "mongo_kinds": 4,
      "pg_kinds": 12,
      "pg_feed": "slot",
      "mongo_processes": 0,
      "pg_processes": 6,
      "items": {
        "mongo": [
          {
            "kind": "replica-set",
            "class": "S",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "replSet + rs.initiate config (3 members, priority 1 / votes 1)"
          },
          {
            "kind": "keyfile",
            "class": "O",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "internal auth between members"
          },
          {
            "kind": "oplog-window-alarm",
            "class": "A",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "an operator must watch the oplog window (rejoin / catch-up needs it)"
          },
          {
            "kind": "feed-cursor-collection",
            "class": "O",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "the change stream's resume token, persisted with the effect"
          }
        ],
        "pg": [
          {
            "kind": "patroni",
            "class": "P",
            "processes": 3,
            "why": "one Patroni agent per node (co-located)"
          },
          {
            "kind": "etcd",
            "class": "P",
            "processes": 3,
            "why": "one etcd member per node (co-located), the DCS quorum"
          },
          {
            "kind": "synchronous-mode",
            "class": "S",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "Patroni synchronous_mode (quorum ANY 1, or classic) + synchronous_commit=on"
          },
          {
            "kind": "replication-role-hba",
            "class": "O",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "the replication role and its pg_hba entry"
          },
          {
            "kind": "rewind-hygiene",
            "class": "S",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "initdb --data-checksums + use_pg_rewind (rejoin after failover)"
          },
          {
            "kind": "physical-slot-wal-retention-alarm",
            "class": "A",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "WAL piles up behind a dead member's physical slot (use_slots)"
          },
          {
            "kind": "wal-level-logical",
            "class": "S",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "wal_level=logical (a restart)"
          },
          {
            "kind": "publication",
            "class": "O",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "the publication on the proof table"
          },
          {
            "kind": "permanent-logical-slot",
            "class": "O",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "a Patroni permanent logical slot (copied to the replicas)"
          },
          {
            "kind": "hot-standby-feedback",
            "class": "S",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "hot_standby_feedback=on (needed for the copied slot)"
          },
          {
            "kind": "slot-retention-alarm",
            "class": "A",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "an operator must watch the slot's retained WAL"
          },
          {
            "kind": "feed-cursor-table",
            "class": "O",
            "processes": 0,
            "why": "the commit-LSN cursor, persisted with the effect"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "flags": []
  },
  "recount": {
    "countedCells": 334,
    "steadyCells": 14,
    "totals": {
      "pss": {
        "cells": 104,
        "writePass": 104,
        "acknowledged": 271105,
        "lostAcknowledged": 0,
        "singleCopyAcks": 0,
        "singleCopyWindows": 0,
        "feeds": {
          "stream": 101
        }
      },
      "classic-strict": {
        "cells": 104,
        "writePass": 104,
        "acknowledged": 296414,
        "lostAcknowledged": 0,
        "singleCopyAcks": 3030,
        "singleCopyWindows": 2,
        "feeds": {
          "outbox": 104,
          "slot": 104,
          "plain": 50
        }
      },
      "quorum-strict": {
        "cells": 116,
        "writePass": 116,
        "acknowledged": 350184,
        "lostAcknowledged": 0,
        "singleCopyAcks": 12537,
        "singleCopyWindows": 12,
        "feeds": {
          "outbox": 116,
          "slot": 116,
          "plain": 52
        }
      },
      "outbox-only": {
        "cells": 10,
        "writePass": 10,
        "acknowledged": 24188,
        "lostAcknowledged": 0,
        "singleCopyAcks": 1565,
        "singleCopyWindows": 1,
        "feeds": {
          "outbox": 10
        }
      }
    },
    "f2bFailingCells": [
      "mongo-pss-default-F2b-rep1-seed1.json",
      "mongo-pss-default-F2b-rep3-seed2.json",
      "mongo-pss-tuned-F2b-rep3-seed2.json"
    ],
    "strictAckCells": [
      {
        "cell": "pg-classic-strict-default-F1-rep1-seed1.json",
        "acks": 1505,
        "windows": 1
      },
      {
        "cell": "pg-classic-strict-tuned-F1-rep4-seed2.json",
        "acks": 1525,
        "windows": 1
      },
      {
        "cell": "pg-quorum-strict-default-F1-rep1-seed1.json",
        "acks": 1630,
        "windows": 1
      },
      {
        "cell": "pg-quorum-strict-default-F2b-rep1-seed2.json",
        "acks": 2148,
        "windows": 1
      },
      {
        "cell": "pg-quorum-strict-default-F2b-rep3-seed1.json",
        "acks": 2171,
        "windows": 1
      },
      {
        "cell": "pg-quorum-strict-floor-F1-rep4-seed2.json",
        "acks": 1525,
        "windows": 1
      },
      {
        "cell": "pg-quorum-strict-tuned-F1-rep0-seed1.json",
        "acks": 1609,
        "windows": 1
      },
      {
        "cell": "pg-quorum-strict-tuned-F1-rep4-seed2.json",
        "acks": 1505,
        "windows": 1
      },
      {
        "cell": "pg-quorum-strict-tuned-F1b-rep1-seed2.json",
        "acks": 1,
        "windows": 1
      },
      {
        "cell": "pg-quorum-strict-tuned-F2b-rep2-seed1.json",
        "acks": 1948,
        "windows": 1
      }
    ],
    "verdictPairValuesChecked": 240
  },
  "limits": [
    "One Windows/WSL2 Docker host, three containerized nodes per arm, simulated partitions; no multi-host reliability claim and no overall winner.",
    "PostgreSQL strict variants logged 15,567 acknowledgements in 10 counted cells while synchronous_standby_names was empty. Zero acknowledged writes were lost. The cause, a true single-copy interval or observer error, is unresolved. Equal two-copy durability throughout is not established; the frozen lost-write gate does not change its verdict for these windows.",
    "Open disturbance window I has no recorded end: five counted seed-2 PostgreSQL files may overlap heavy test work. One is a compared default/F1 value; removing it leaves the sign unchanged. That sensitivity check does not prove clean-run provenance.",
    "PostgreSQL variants are selected on seed1 and compared on seed1. Seed2 outage numbers are out of sample; its gate outcomes participate in selection.",
    "F1b, the Patroni floor and the non-strict outbox-only overhead block are labelled context, never deciding a compared verdict. The overhead block does not isolate slot cost from the strict/non-strict difference.",
    "Source cells, runner, raw logs and original checksum manifest remain private. Hashes identify records, not correctness or independent replication. This publication recount checks all 334 cell identities and 240 verdict pair values but does not rerun the databases or independently audit all 6020 manifest entries.",
    "Original result advocate reviews are reviews of earlier drafts with vetoes and requested remedies, not final acceptance of this publication. The reported corrections are traceable; final publication review is recorded separately by the landing process."
  ],
  "report": "experiments/failover/results/RESULT.md",
  "sourceHashes": "experiments/failover/results/publication-sources.json"
}
